So last night was my Fiction Writing class. The class started at 6:30, and after some shuffling around rooms because the one we normally use had a leak, the professor wanted to start by talking over my story. By 8:15, we took a break. The entire time the professor was like "We're over time, but I don't care; I want to keep talking about this."
Without reading through every single comment, I got a general vibe of feedback: the description's a little too heavy in spots, there's not enough of where Shannon's mind is during it, and the ending is sudden and weak. Conversely, I got numerous comments that the writing was very good, the story was enjoyable, and the action was well-written. One person thought that it wasn't a short story at all, but the first chapter of a book. Another comment was that my description of the action scene was so vivid that it made the reader ill. Most everyone in the group liked it overall.
The professor was the most critical, but for two main reasons. One, he's not a fan of genre fiction (and "Bete Noire" is, effectively, modern fantasy/horror), and two, he thinks I have enough talent to be able to try something truly literary. At the same time, he said that not everything we write needs to be literary. Sometimes, we just like to read good stories, and he said that "Bete Noire" is a good story.
So, I'm going to probably read over all of the comments tonight, and then put everything away for a while and think on it. Right now, I'm tentatively considering rewriting the whole thing in first person (which, I think, will get rid of some of the problems) and try a few different endings. I have a few vague ideas for tweaks of the plot and style of the piece. However, the point is that people who have already commented on it or offering to comment again might want to hold off, as there's a good chance the next version will be completely different. And who knows? Maybe there is a book in there.
My story was ripped to pieces, and I couldn't be happier about it.
